Happened to be grabbing a coffee @ Dunkin before heading home to WV & grabbed just a large cheese..... opened the box & my wife was not very happy, I guess it reminded her of a pizza joint we’ve previously ate at maybe she wasn’t a fan of but I convinced her to just take a bite & if she didn’t like it I wouldn’t bother her anymore..... It’s literately the best pizza we’ve had in such a long time! The crust is actually crispy but not burnt, the cheese is gooey but done, it literately was just so delicious, I never write reviews but this place I had to say something about given we never eat in Hagerstown unless just grabbing a cheapy pizza from Sam’s Club! I give 5 stars for overall experience, my only complaint would be the space right by the doors you walk in. It’s a little tight there but doable for something so good!

First time. Easy phone ordering, friendly employee, short wait time for Saturday night. Food was ready when I got there, and hot and accurate. Only downfall was the honey mustard cup melted in the kids tenders so it was a little messy, honest mistake. I've never had new york pizza so I can't talk to the authenticity. I picked it up but they offer delivery through door dash. I couldn't locate a menu online but there is a basic one in the door dash app. The bread is fresh, the pizza is delicious and the price is equal to other places throughout town and they have a few deals as well to help with the price. Someone asked in the parking lot if they were any good and I told them I didn't know... so I wanted to leave a review here so others can see it and try it for themselves!

I stopped in this evening after mowing and grabbed some food. We picked up a cheese steak sub, fries, and a large pizza. Everything was excellent and cooked perfectly. The sub had plenty of meat on it along with all the toppings. I will certainly go back.

My GF and I take alot of random road trips and day trips and one late morning decided to drive to Hagerstown to eat lunch. We got a little sidetracked by stopping at a few of the outlet stores and didn't have the time to go in and eat anywhere, since I had to be back for work at 5. Take out or fast food was the only options and I wasn't driving 3 hours round trip for McDonald's. I love Pizza and im a pizza snob, I like it how I like it and have went on several day trips to Jersey just for Pizza. This place was what I went with and my instincts were on point. After reading reviews and getting an idea of what the pizza "SHOULD" be like, I ordered cheese pizza with pepperoni. It was great... nice sauce that wasn't to tart and not too sweet. Cheese tasted great and the crust was pretty much on point. I like a little char to my crust and it was on point as well. Not floppy and most impressive was the fact that it wasn't overly greasy... which can be hard to pull off with pepperoni... I didn't have any grease drips.. so that was a plus. I think I used one napkin. My GF got an Italian panini and I finished what she couldn't and it was excellent. It was more like a sandwich, not the traditional panini look persay, but damn it was good. The meats and cheeses tasted like a mom n pop top notch deli that's been around for 100 years... overall, I'd recommend this place, ill be back again and out of the 3 Pizza places I've been to in Hagerstown, all rated 4.5 or higher, this one, imo, is the best without hesitation. The guy who rang me up was really friendly and outgoing. Great stop!!

The food I have to say is absolutely great. I got a backyard burger. It was 2 patties loaded with goodness. The hand cut fries are addictive. Lol best burger joint in this area. I had to cut it in half just to eat it. Love this place. Please go enjoy their great food. You def get your moneys worth. A must try. Awesome place!

Excellent food! I have zero complaints or suggestions other than for them to keep doing what they’re doing. The restaurant was clean, staff were extremely nice and very attentive. Prices are great! The food was fresh and delicious. Subs are made on homemade bread and fries are fresh cut fries. Excellent lunch specials as well. Highly recommend!

Best pizza we have found. Good ratio of toppings to cheese to sauce. Dough is fresh. Cooked to the perfect doneness. We drive here from WV. Everything is clean. Attentive service. Appears like do more takeout than eat-in, the dining room doesn't have a ton of tables. However, we appreciate the tv trivia entertainment.

Clean place and the staff is nice and professional. Pub style and regular style seating. Pickle pizza is sold as a whole pizza and you can get other pizzas in slice. The haddock fish sandwich is so moist and well prepared love it. I’ll be back again.